The Best Domino’s Pizza Toppings for a Custom Pizza Night

A custom pizza night is the perfect way to get creative with your favorite flavors, experiment with unique combinations, and enjoy a fun dining experience with family or friends. Domino’s makes it easy to design your ideal pizza from a wide selection of toppings, sauces, and crust options. Whether you prefer classic combinations or like to think outside the box, there’s something for everyone.

In this guide, we’ll explore some of the best Domino’s pizza toppings that will take your custom pizza to the next level. So grab your favorite ingredients, fire up the oven, and get ready for a pizza night you won’t forget!

1. Classic Favorites That Never Fail

There’s a reason why some toppings are classics—they’re delicious, familiar, and universally loved. These tried-and-true favorites will give your pizza a timeless, comforting flavor that everyone can enjoy.

Pepperoni

Pepperoni is a pizza topping legend, and for good reason. The slightly spicy, smoky, and savory flavor of pepperoni complements the rich, melty cheese and tomato sauce perfectly. For an extra indulgent pizza, add double pepperoni or combine it with another meat like sausage or bacon.

Perfect combo: Pepperoni + mozzarella + extra sauce.

Sausage

Whether you go for mild Italian sausage or spicy sausage, this topping brings a rich, savory flavor to your pizza. It pairs wonderfully with other meats or vegetables like mushrooms, onions, or green peppers, making it versatile enough for any type of pizza.

Perfect combo: Sausage + mushrooms + green peppers + mozzarella.

Bacon

Bacon is the king of crispy toppings, adding a smoky richness that enhances any pizza. The salty crunch of bacon is an ideal contrast to the softness of melted cheese and juicy meats. It’s perfect for combining with everything from pepperoni to chicken or even veggies.

Perfect combo: Bacon + chicken + mozzarella + BBQ sauce.

2. Fresh and Flavorful Veggies

If you’re looking for a lighter pizza or simply want to add some crunch and freshness, veggies are an excellent way to go. Not only do they taste great, but they add vibrant colors and nutrients to your pie!

Mushrooms

Mushrooms bring an earthy flavor that complements rich cheeses and meats. Their soft texture works perfectly with crunchy toppings like onions and peppers. Whether you’re creating a vegetarian pizza or adding mushrooms to a meatier pie, they’re always a great choice.

Perfect combo: Mushrooms + green peppers + onions + mozzarella.

Green Peppers

Green peppers are a crisp, slightly sweet topping that balances out savory flavors. Their mild heat adds depth to pizzas without overpowering the other ingredients. Try them with sausage, bacon, or even a spicy sauce for a well-rounded flavor.

Perfect combo: Green peppers + sausage + onions + mozzarella.

Onions

Onions add sweetness and a bit of bite to your pizza. Whether you go with red, white, or caramelized onions, they provide a wonderful contrast to the rich flavors of cheese and meats. Onions work beautifully with almost every topping, making them a must-have for a custom pizza.

Perfect combo: Onions + black olives + green peppers + mozzarella.

Spinach

Spinach is a fantastic way to add a healthy touch to your pizza while giving it a fresh, slightly earthy flavor. Pair spinach with feta cheese, garlic, and a drizzle of olive oil for a Mediterranean-inspired masterpiece.

Perfect combo: Spinach + feta cheese + tomatoes + mozzarella.

Black Olives

Black olives provide a briny, tangy flavor that works well with savory meats like sausage and bacon. They’re an excellent way to balance out the richness of cheese while adding a unique taste.

Perfect combo: Black olives + sausage + green peppers + mozzarella.

3. Unique Additions for Bold Flavor

Looking to spice things up? These toppings are perfect for adding an extra layer of flavor and excitement to your pizza. Bold, spicy, or indulgent, these ingredients will make your pizza stand out.

Buffalo Chicken

For those who love a bit of heat, buffalo chicken is an excellent topping. The tangy buffalo sauce adds a spicy kick to the tender chicken, and it pairs wonderfully with blue cheese or ranch for a zesty and bold pizza.

Perfect combo: Buffalo chicken + red onions + mozzarella + ranch drizzle.

Jalapeños

If you’re craving heat, jalapeños are the topping for you. Their sharp, spicy flavor pairs perfectly with meats like sausage or pepperoni. If you like a little extra kick, try adding jalapeños alongside bacon and chicken for a bold and fiery pizza.

Perfect combo: Jalapeños + pepperoni + sausage + mozzarella.

Pineapple

Pineapple is perfect for anyone who enjoys the sweet-and-savory combination. While some people might be hesitant to add fruit to pizza, pineapple’s juicy sweetness perfectly complements savory toppings like ham and bacon. Try it on a classic Hawaiian or get creative with other ingredients.

Perfect combo: Pineapple + ham + mozzarella + a drizzle of BBQ sauce.

BBQ Chicken

BBQ chicken is a flavorful, tangy topping that gives your pizza a smoky-sweet flavor. The barbecue sauce pairs perfectly with grilled chicken and melted cheese, creating a savory pie that’s bursting with flavor.

Perfect combo: BBQ chicken + red onions + cilantro + mozzarella.

Anchovies

Anchovies are a bold choice for those who love intense, salty flavors. These little fish add a briny, umami-rich taste to your pizza and pair well with savory ingredients like olives, capers, and tomatoes. For adventurous eaters, anchovies are a must-try.

Perfect combo: Anchovies + black olives + red onions + mozzarella.

4. Cheesy Goodness to Finish Strong

What’s pizza without cheese? While mozzarella is the classic choice, there are other cheeses that can elevate your pizza experience and add rich, complex flavors.

Double Mozzarella

If you love cheese, there’s no such thing as too much mozzarella. Adding extra mozzarella to your pizza ensures that every bite is extra cheesy and gooey. For cheese lovers, this is a must-have!

Perfect combo: Double mozzarella + pepperoni + sausage + bacon.

Cheddar Cheese

Cheddar cheese adds a sharp, tangy flavor that enhances any pizza. Combine it with mozzarella for a balanced, cheesy pie that’s bursting with flavor. It pairs especially well with BBQ or buffalo chicken.

Perfect combo: Cheddar cheese + BBQ chicken + red onions + cilantro.

Feta Cheese

Feta cheese is tangy and crumbly, adding a Mediterranean flair to your pizza. It’s perfect when paired with fresh vegetables like spinach and tomatoes or meats like grilled chicken.

Perfect combo: Feta cheese + spinach + black olives + tomatoes.

5. Crust Options to Complement Your Toppings

Now that you’ve picked your toppings, don’t forget to consider the crust! Domino’s offers a variety of crust options that can enhance the overall pizza experience. Whether you prefer a classic hand-tossed crust, a crunchy thin crust, or something more indulgent like stuffed crust, the right base will help bring all your toppings together.

Perfect combo: Hand-tossed crust + pepperoni + extra cheese + jalapeños.

Conclusion: Create Your Perfect Custom Pizza

With so many options to choose from, a custom pizza night is the perfect opportunity to experiment with different toppings and create the pizza of your dreams. From classic favorites like pepperoni and sausage to bold choices like buffalo chicken and anchovies, there’s something for everyone. Don’t be afraid to mix and match and discover new combinations you’ll love.

Next time you’re craving a pizza night, use this guide to craft the perfect pie, complete with all your favorite toppings. And remember, the best part of making a custom pizza is that you get to be the chef!

Business Information

Business Name: Nittany Pizza

Address: 2073 Springwood Road, York, PA, 17403

Phone: (717) 650-2648

E-mail: nittanypizza@comcast.net

Owner: Athanasios Drivas

Website: nittanypizza.com

Facebook: facebook.com/nittanypizza

Twitter: twitter.com/nittanypizza

LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/nittanypizza

YouTube: youtube.com/@NittanyPizza

Instagram: instagram.com/nittanypizza

Pinterest: pinterest.com/nittanypizza

Source: Domino’s Pizza Toppings List

Hashtags: #nittanypizza #veganpizza #pizza